The Online Photographer

Check out our new site at www.theonlinephotographer.com!

Sunday, June 25, 2006

Rip It to Shreds

Okay, by request—anybody brave enough to submit a picture for a critique? I've got to warn you, though, I'll probably rip it to shreds. So please don't ask unless you have thick skin and can take it.

P.S. Just one, please!

Posted by: MIKE JOHNSTON

56 Comments:

Blogger fivetonsflax said...

Hmm. You want a picture I'm proud of, or one that doesn't quite work and I don't know why?

Signed, someone who's never quite understood the whole photo critique concept.

11:48 PM  
Blogger fivetonsflax said...

Here are some photos. If any of them spark a reaction from you, I'd love to hear about it, even if you do rip it to shreds. You will be better than me at picking a photo that interests you.

11:50 PM  
Blogger alkos said...

Hi Mike!

Ok, I'm the brave one ;-)
Here's you go:

http://stefanski.one.pl/~alkos/pixelpost/index.php?showimage=166

This is the one of my own that - at the moment - I like the best :) Note: it's a pure candid :), shot during St. Patrick Parade in Dublin this year - not a setup, as well as rest of my photographs. Feel free to choose any other if you don't find this one bad enough :P :P

cheers

alkos
--
http://pad.go.pl

11:52 PM  
Blogger John Bates said...

I can take it. I never like my own pictures, anyway.

12:04 AM  
Blogger aizan said...

pick me!

http://static.flickr.com/28/42810168_5d1acb381a.jpg?v=0

12:22 AM  
Blogger shaggy dog pix said...

Hi, Mike. I'm tragically bad at proper web manipulation, so, here's a link that'll take you to a photo. It's the one for June 16th that I'm submitting for shredding. Although you may get better ones ("better" as in they're really, really good, or they're really, really bad).

http://shaggydogpix.blogspot.com/2006_06_01_shaggydogpix_archive.html

12:28 AM  
Blogger canfraggle said...

I'd be more than willing but how do we get it to you? Could post it on a website and link it via a comment?

12:46 AM  
Blogger lekke said...

I'm brave enough!
And just so I don't get to ponder which one from my Flickr photostream I should submit, let's use the last one I've posted

http://www.flickr.com/photos/lekke/171455661/

fire away!

1:11 AM  
Blogger John said...

This blog does not allow anonymous comments.

So one has to create a blog site in order to post here? I had a picture for you to critique but I'm certainly not going to that much trouble in order to give you an address for it.

In the lingo of the youngsters, that sucks.

1:26 AM  
Blogger John said...

I'm thick skinned, have fun.
http://homepage.mac.com/drjohn/.Pictures/liongirl.jpg

1:29 AM  
Blogger Anders Ocklind said...

Mike
I want to send my picture for riping.
How to send it?
Anders

1:52 AM  
Blogger Anders Ocklind said...

Mike
I want to send my picture for riping.
How to send it?
Anders

1:55 AM  
Blogger Alfonso said...

May I be the first?

Try with this one:
http://www.photo.net/photodb/photo?photo_id=3745626

or any of the ones shown in

http://www.photo.net/photos/goros

I would really appreciate your critics.

Cheers

Alfonso

2:21 AM  
Blogger Paul Leidl said...

Hi Mike:

Regarding your "challenge" for someone to submit a photograph for your perusal...here is a picture I made while living in Norway many moons ago. I called it "ballet school".

Best regards,

Paul

PS I am brand new at the blogging thing so I hope the photograph comes through.
If not, please look at my blog site-Paul Leidl's Blog.

2:31 AM  
Blogger Peterbkk said...

OK
Which email?
Peter

2:40 AM  
Blogger eric kellerman said...

I'm willing ... if I have the right of reply!!!

3:09 AM  
Blogger JeffH said...

OK Mike, I'll bite. Here's a link to two portrates, take your pick.
http://www.hdmarketing.com/Photos_For_Critique_06-25-06/index.htm

Jeff H

3:12 AM  
Blogger Ray said...

I'm game, how do I post an image?

3:18 AM  
Blogger Ray said...

I'm game, how do I post an image?

3:19 AM  
Blogger Colin [auspiciousdragon.net] said...

Mike,

Not sure if you simply mean send you links. But if so, what about this one:

http://www.auspiciousdragon.net/today/index.php?showimage=8

3:20 AM  
Blogger Krakowian said...

I'll take you up on your offer! I didn't see a way to email you, so I'm posting in the comments.

Hi. I've been reading your writings online for several years now on Luminous Landscape and Photo.net. Honestly speaking, you are my favorite commentator on photography. In fact, I've pretty much given up reading most of the others, except occasionally. :-) Maybe because it's your love of the "unlovable", such as Pentax, but your opinion to me, carries more weight with me than others'.

Therefore, I would be honored to have you tear apart one of my photos. :-) I'm not a great photographer, but I do have one photo which I would appreciate your critiquing. I took it last fall near Niagara Falls.

Oddly enough, while I sort of like this photo, I don't consider it to be a particularly good photo, and certainly not very compelling. I suppose it would make a good post card (which is about the best you could say for any of my photos) But it keeps drawing me back somehow, and I don't know why. In any case, you won't hurt my feelings by trashing this particular photo, and I would be amazed and flattered by any positive words that may find their way inadvertently or otherwise into your critique.

Here is the link to the photo. If you do decide to critique my photo, and wish to have a full-sized version, you can email me for it. I believe my email address is accessible to you.

http://webaperture.com/gallery/photos/60797

-Jon Glass

3:30 AM  
Blogger Tim Fischer said...

I'm game, here are 2 in fact! ;)

http://www.users.on.net/~timfischer/luckydragon/pblog2/pblog2_35.jpg

http://www.users.on.net/~timfischer/luckydragon/pblog2/pblog2_16.jpg

4:54 AM  
Blogger bomath said...

http://www.fotolog.com/bomath/?pid=14691804

Fire it up!
...if I'm not too late to the party. You can safely asume that a) I'm eager to hear some ways to enhance my technique (pre- or post taking a pic like that) and b) I can take a „throw it away alongside your equipment, there's no hope” if that would be the case.

4:55 AM  
Blogger Tim Fischer said...

Dear me, I didn't see your note about only 1 photo. What a kerfuffle.

4:56 AM  
Blogger Andre said...

OK, please critique

http://picasaweb.google.com/eulevik/BestPhotosOf2004/photo#4940408893094625298

6:03 AM  
Blogger Brandon J. Scott said...

I'm game, but I can't find a way to insert animage. Here is the URL:

http://www.brandonjscott.com/imgs/20060617004.jpg

Have at it, Brandon

6:05 AM  
Blogger Paul said...

Alright Mike, have at it. [Entitled "Little Church - Entry Island".

6:35 AM  
Blogger thinkanythingonce said...

Ok, I'm game.
http://photos.smartbean.us/misc/dsc_1929-01.jpg

6:42 AM  
Blogger akikana said...

Okay, this one please?

HERE

Thanks
Guy

6:54 AM  
Blogger jamietie said...

I'd be happy to submit one. How can I get it to you?

7:11 AM  
Blogger the blind spot said...

Where do you want these images to be sent for shredding?

7:23 AM  
Blogger ENS said...

I'll post one...how do I do it? Email it to you?

8:02 AM  
Blogger ricardo said...

here u go:

http://www.ricardofranca.com/images/taquile.jpg

shoot/shred away...

p.s.: i like it, even if it's under-exposed and the colors aren't that nice (though i do have some trouble getting good colors out of under-exposed slides with my scanner/software)

8:10 AM  
Blogger Andy Smith said...

Now I don't know if he's serious or not! ;)
Andy

8:39 AM  
Blogger Max said...

I'd like to send one, but how is it done? Should I send it to an email adress?

8:41 AM  
Blogger Dibutil Ftalat said...

Hey, be my guest!
This one is my favorite, the caption translates:
"What else did we forget?"

Thanks! ;-)

8:55 AM  
Blogger Chris said...

Mike,

I'll have a go at it:

http://www.pbase.com/copcarss/image/31939678

This is a shot I took in Yellowstone National Park in 2004. I used a Canon 10D with a (rented, unfortunately) 300mm f2.8L IS. It's actually one of the few pictures I've taken that I actually like, and haven't found anything to critique myself on.

Would love to hear another's viewpoint on it.

Thanks!

Chris

9:04 AM  
Blogger david adam edelstein said...

Don't all rush in at once... :-)

OK, I'll start. http://www.noise-to-signal.com/2006/06/banana_leaf.html

Be brutal :-)

9:08 AM  
Blogger wirehead said...

http://www.flickr.com/photos/cyberspace/102633812/

9:20 AM  
Blogger Peter said...

Ok... I'll bite. How about
this:

It's a mountain in Alaska near Denali named the Moose's Tooth. It was taken on a
climbing trip in April with an Olympus E-300 & 14-54 lens.

9:22 AM  
Blogger eric kellerman said...

I thought I had offered. In case it didn't get through first time, I'm offering ... as long as I have the right of reply!

9:24 AM  
Blogger Matt Wade said...

Ok, go ahead and rip it up in my blog. I'm feeling suicidal today. hehe...

9:27 AM  
Blogger Matt Wade said...

Ok. Rip it up... I'm suicidal.

9:29 AM  
Blogger Pedja Pavlicic said...

Not without trepidation...
http://www.flickr.com/photos/pedjap/146783211/

9:59 AM  
Blogger Greg Barnett said...

http://grandviewphoto.com/clients/20050717-0/4500028.jpg

"mara bridge"

Rip it to shreds Mike!

10:11 AM  
Blogger Josh said...

Mike, How do I submit my picture?

10:14 AM  
Blogger StephaneB said...

OK, I'll try... but where should I send it?

10:14 AM  
Blogger StephaneB said...

OK, I'll try... but where should I send it?

10:14 AM  
Blogger StephaneB said...

OK, I'll try. But where should I send it?

10:15 AM  
Blogger Clint said...

Rip away:

http://static.flickr.com/63/174429872_70a06c792d_b.jpg

10:16 AM  
Blogger sbug said...

I've got thick skin, critique away! How about this one:
http://www.flickr.com/photos/sbugphoto/171008096/
Frankly, you could critique any photos of mine if you'd prefer another one.

-Scott

10:39 AM  
Blogger Michael Yakovis said...

This is my last picture:
http://yakovis.com/lj/photo/2006.06.25_lensbaby/_mg_5772.jpg

Thanx!

10:51 AM  
Blogger Chris said...

Mike,

Forgot to mention that the photograph I submitted (along with the others from that trip) earned this comment in my guestbook:

"The Canon is not a 2/14 2/14 and trying to make it one is not good. You have more to think about than the format. the 2/14 is boring and so is the 35mm. Composition, post processing, subject matter is very lacking. A camera, lens or other equipment no matter how good or expensive does not make the photographer. I am sorry, but you should look at a lot of other photos and go to books or museums to see what makes a good photo. Shoot a lot, and do not post out of focus, badly composed, no contrast and boring photos. Make yourself proud of what you see, and photograph, and do it well.

Howard Horwich
horwich@sbcglobal.net"

I'm not sure if you could rip my work into shreds any smaller than that or not, but feel free to try if the mood hits you! ;-)

Chris

11:01 AM  
Blogger David said...

I would love to submit an image so you can "rip it to shreds" since all I can do is improve. I have been successful in several juried shows this year, but I am lightyears away from the quality and vision that can make my work special. Web critiques by strangers with unknown credentials have outlived their usefulness for me. How can I submit an image to you for the "bloodletting" I so richly deserve?

11:17 AM  
Blogger Salva said...

So everybody is sending their photographs... here's mine http://www.flickr.com/photo_zoom.gne?id=129601203&size=o

I'm Salvador Moreno from Spain, and I am a highschool teacher with free time for photography.

11:35 AM  
Blogger Zach Matthews said...

Hahaha, Mike, I'm just amazed you didn't see this coming. I'm a 1/10th qualified jack-booted writer somebody handed a camera to and I get emails all the time asking for my "professional opinion" as to this or that photo. Getting a guy as clearly well-informed and interested in the art of photography as yourself to hold his hand out and say, 'Sure, I'll critique your image' is an internet auteur's wet dream. Just do us all a favor and, in fact, rip them to shreds. The photos you've already posted are gorgeous. This is like American Photo Idol, Mike! We want dross! Lots of dross!

Hahahahahahah.

5:31 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home